

Penny was born on December 5, 1942, in Toronto, Ontario. Childhood highlights included visits to her grandparents’ summer home in Sarnia, Ontario. That is, until her parents bought the cottage (Jackson’s Folly) in Honey Harbour, Ontario, when Penny was nine. Honey Harbour became her heart home, a love affair that endured until the day she died.
Penny was a true beauty, attracting all manner of suitors. Yet it was on a trip with her mother to New Brunswick in 1965 for a wedding that she met her first husband, Prescott (Scott) Nickerson, with whom she had two children, Stephanie and Bart.
As the wife of a sales executive, Penny channelled her personable nature into becoming the “hostess with the mostest”. During her time in Calgary, Alberta, she threw herself into the Junior League, in addition to hosting innumerable dinners for Scott’s business colleagues.
Alas, that marriage was not to be, and she returned to her hometown of Toronto with young Stephanie and Bart to begin a new chapter in her life. On the rocks of the schoolhouse on a Regatta-day weekend in Honey Harbour, Penny met Norman Buchanan, her second husband, and the man with whom she would share almost 50 years.
Penny loved her job as a receptionist, first at the law firm Stephens French McEwan, and later at “the ship of fools,” as she affectionately referred to the next group of lawyers she wrangled from her reception desk. Every morning, she would take the 142 Nortown Express bus from Avenue Road down to the financial district. She made lifelong friends of many of her “bus buddies,” and was so fond of the regular bus driver that she made the news for organizing a retirement party for him – on the bus! One of the best perks of her job was that she had her summers off so she could spend her time in Honey Harbour.
Penny was most in her element in Honey Harbour. She was a regular presence on the tennis court, helped to organize the annual Steak-In (later Julyfest) at the schoolhouse, working the phones to get everyone to bring a salad, and was a central figure at every ladies’ luncheon. Oh, and let’s not forget her shrimp mould, which she brought to any party she attended! A quasi-monarchist (or maybe it was just another excuse to host a party), Penny threw two mimosa-fuelled royal wedding parties (one for (then) Prince Charles and Diana, the other for (then) Prince Andrew and Sarah Ferguson) that started at 6 o’clock in the morning and ran well into the afternoon.
Penny loved any excuse to dress up. She was always particular about her wardrobe and had a fondness for shoes that may have bordered on obsession. There is no doubt that the salespeople at David’s and Town Shoes downtown were bereft when Penny retired. It’s also how she became “Granny Shoes” to grandchildren Kyra, Jade, and Rhys.
When she retired to Aurora, Penny and Norman cultivated new friendships within the community of Beacon Hall. Making friends with the restaurant manager at the golf club, Penny was always able to reserve the corner table for holiday events, most especially Mother’s Day, which was arguably her favourite holiday. Her later years brought more than their share of health challenges. Through it all, Norman cared for her with unwavering devotion.
Penny made fast friends, but her dearest friends loved her for who she was and remained steadfastly loyal to her throughout her life.
She was predeceased by both of her parents (Marda and Bill) and her beloved brother Hayes. She leaves behind her husband, Norman; children Stephanie Nickerson (Tracy) and Bart Nickerson (Matthew); stepchildren Ross Buchanan (Brenda) and Beth Buchanan (John); grandchildren Kyra (Alex), Jade (Dalton), and Rhys (Hannah); and her sister, Jessica Walker.
If you’re inclined, raise a toast to Penny. A celebration of life will be held in the spring of 2027 when it’s warmer. Penny hated the cold.
In lieu of flowers, a donation to The Kidney Foundation of Canada would be lovely.
DONATIONS
SHARE OBITUARYSHARE
v.1.18.1