Andrew "Andy" Francis Fagnoni

Andrew “Andy” Fagnoni, 69, passed on November 6th, 2025 in Tallahassee, Florida surrounded by loved ones. He is preceded in death by his parents, Robert and Mary; and four siblings, Robert, Richard, Lawrence, and Maria. He is survived by his daughters, Gabrielle and Julia; his granddaughters, Tori, Rain, Reagan, and Daisy; siblings, Jeanette and Nick; son-in-law, Forest; and a multitude of friends and family members.

Andy was born in New York City on March 8th, 1956. He played football and baseball for the Scarsdale Raiders during high school as a star player. After high school, he attended Cornell University with longtime friend Steve Gulotta. During his career as a restaurant general manager, Andy was the recipient of numerous awards. After retiring from the restaurant industry, he worked in the liquor store at a Tallahassee Publix. He made many donations, monetarily and of

his time, to numerous charities local and worldwide.

Andy had an unforgettable laugh and a strong personality. He loved to cook and had a recommendation for a bottle of wine with every meal. Forever an active man, if he wasn’t on a trip in Italy, he was planning one. He was a loyal friend, a true Catholic, and the best dad his girls could have asked for.

A Memorial Mass will be held at Good Shepherd Catholic Church, located at 4665 Thomasville Rd, Tallahassee, Florida, 32309. The service is scheduled for November 11, 2025, from 11:00 am to 12:00 pm.

In lieu of flowers, we ask that donations be made to local charities.