Michelle was married to Shannon Hartsfield on October 11, 1999. In addition to her faithfulness as a wife and mother, she worked as an administrative assistant at MetLife.
Michelle is survived by one daughter, Ann Kathryn; two sons, Reed and Will; parents, Sam and Vickie Messick; mother- and father-in-law, Luke and Patricia Hartsfield; one brother, Lee Messick (Krystal); and two brothers-in-law, Chuck Hartsfield (Jennifer) and Chad Hartsfield (Megan).