

October 31, 1965 – October 22, 2026
A Life of Faith, Laughter, Love, and a Little Bit of Magic
William Timothy Shumaker, affectionately known to countless friends, family members, and children as “Papa Shu,” passed from this earthly life into the arms of his Lord and Savior on October 22, 2026, just nine days shy of his 61st birthday.
2 Timothy 4:7
“I have fought a good fight, I have finished my course, I have kept the faith.”
Born on October 31, 1965, to William “Bill” and Lorena Jane “Jan” Shumaker, Timothy grew up in a family rooted in faith, love, and the importance of serving others.
A beloved husband, father of two daughters, grandfather to three granddogs, United States Navy veteran, children’s minister, magician, balloon artist, and storyteller, Papa Shu lived a life dedicated to bringing joy to others and sharing the love of Jesus Christ.
To know Papa Shu was to know laughter. Whether he was telling one of his famously long stories, performing a magic trick, making balloon animals for delighted children, or sharing the Gospel, he had a remarkable gift for making people feel loved, welcomed, and important.
His mother, Lorena Jane Reynolds Shumaker, once chose a special Scripture for her son William Timothy:
1 Timothy 4:14
“Do not neglect the gift that is in you.”
And what a beautiful testimony his life became to those very words.
Papa Shu never neglected the gifts God placed within him. Instead, he spent his years sharing them generously. His hands created wonders, his stories inspired laughter, and his heart pointed others toward Christ.
He was a man of strong faith, a playful spirit, and a heart for children. Through his years serving in children’s ministry, he found great happiness in making the world a little brighter for those around him.
On February 14, 1987, Timothy married his beloved wife, Penny Shumaker. Together, they built a life filled with faith, family, laughter, and memories that will be treasured for generations.
But beyond the magic, the ministry, and the stories, his greatest earthly treasure was his family. To the world, he was Papa Shu. To his daughters, he was simply Dad, a title they considered one of life’s greatest privileges.
Family and Loved Ones
Timothy was preceded in death by his parents, William “Bill” and Lorena Jane “Jan” Shumaker; his sister, Rebecca Shumaker; his brother, Daniel Shumaker; and his sister-in-law, Linda Shumaker, wife of his brother David.
He leaves behind his beloved wife of 39 years, Penny Shumaker; their two daughters, Brittany and Tabitha Shumaker; Penny’s mother Ann Elliott affectionately called nana who saw Tim as her own son; their family dogs, Ping Pong and Ellie Mae; and his three cherished granddogs, Nyx, Hexia, and Gingie.
He is also survived by his brother, David Shumaker, and his sister, Dawn Shumaker Smith.
Through his brother David, he leaves behind his niece, Rebecca Eidt, and her husband, Sean Eidt, along with their three children, Jacob, Arya, and Eden.
Through his sister Dawn, he leaves behind his niece, Pricilla Mims; his nephew, Paul Mims, and Paul’s wife, Kristi; and their four sons, Bryce, Maddox, Oliver, and Legend.
His extended family also includes Kellye and Michael Edge; Zack and Kyler Casterline, with Hannah and Abigail; Joshua and Ariel Bailey, with Maggie, Charlie, and Jace; Aleb and Chaz Bailey, with Gabe, Mckynleigh, and Kaiden; Justin and Jordann Edge, with Emma, Ellie, and Theron; Corrie Edge, with Archer; and Elijah Edge.
He also leaves behind extended family members, dear friends, fellow believers, and the many children and families whose lives he touched through his ministry, storytelling, magic, and kindness.
A Legacy of Faith and Joy
His life was not measured merely by the years he lived, but by the lives he touched, the laughter he inspired, the lessons he taught, and the love he left behind.
Though he will be deeply missed, his family takes comfort in knowing that he is now rejoicing in the presence of his Lord and Savior. The gifts he shared, the faith he lived, and the love he gave will continue through all those who knew him.
Psalm 150:6
“Let every thing that hath breath praise the LORD. Praise ye the LORD.”
A verse treasured by his mother, and a fitting reminder of the legacy of praise and faith passed from one generation to the next.
FAMILY
Penny ShumakerWife
Brittanny and Tabitha ShumakerDaughters
David ShumakerBrother
Dawn Shumaker SmithSister
William "Bill" and Lorena Jane "Jan" ShumakerParents (deceased)
Rebecca ShumakerSister (deceased)
Daniel ShumakerBrother (deceased)
Linda ShumakerSister-in-law (deceased)
SHARE OBITUARYSHARE
v.1.18.1