Phyllis Jean Hartenstein

Phyllis was the beloved wife of Gerald Hartenstein, and together they raised three amazing daughters: Eileen Carlotto, Renee Macleod, and Dina Rescott. Phyllis was also blessed with a large and loving family of grandchildren and great-grandchildren, all of whom adored her.

She is survived by her daughter Eileen and her husband Mark Carlotto, and their children: Kayli Tolan and her husband RJ, and their children Nellie, River, and Cy; Noah Cherry and his wife Helaina Matza, and their daughter Eliana; and Katie and Hayley Carlotto.

She is also survived by her daughter Renee and her husband John Macleod, and their children: Brett and Elise Macleod, and their children Charlotte, Margot, and Ari; and Rachel and her husband Patrick Deeney, and their children Leeland and Mara Bess.

She is also survived by her daughter Dina and her husband Fred Rescott, and their children: Lindsay and her husband Pat Lyons, and their children Sunny and Cal; and Carli and Jeremy Rescott.

Family was everything to Phyllis. She never missed a celebration, always dressed in her signature style — leopard print and New York black. On her 90th birthday, the whole family honored her iconic look by dressing head to toe in leopard, even the men. It was a sight to behold, and she loved every minute of it.

Phyllis had a sharp wit and a dry sense of humor that was entirely her own. When the family wrote poems for milestone birthdays, her roasts were always the best of the bunch — pointed, hilarious, and perfectly on target. She loved to shop, especially for jewelry and antiques, and ran her own antique and jewelry business for many years. She cherished her many friends and was a devoted Mets fan through and through. She wore high heels in the kitchen and lit up whenever the family gathered for a meal, a celebration, or just because.

Her grandchildren adored her, whether they were talking Mets baseball, comparing notes on nails and hair, or just soaking up her company — and her great-grandchildren found her every bit as charming and funny. No one could ever put anything past her. "I know," she'd say. "I'm a witch."

We loved her a lot, and she will be truly missed. As she would always say, "What's not to love?"

She was preceded in death by her husband, Gerald Hartenstein, and her parents, Paul and Bess Antman.

In lieu of flowers, donations may be made to Hadassah or the ASPCA, two of her favorite charities.