Sandra Jane McColley Fenstermaker, age 87, passed on January 5, 2026. Sandy was born to Cleo (Click) and Robert O. McColley. She was preceded in death by her husband of 65 years, Allan Fenstermaker; sisters Kay Greiner and Anne Campbell and brother James Click. She is survived by her children Lee (Bea) Fenstermaker, Scott (Dorri) Fenstermaker, Tracy (Claudio) Garcia and Stacy (Mike) Overly; ten grandchildren and five great-grandchildren.
Sandy was a 1956 graduate of North High School in Columbus. She had an unwavering faith in God and was a long-time member of Berean Bible Church in Dublin where she had many friends. Sandy dearly loved her family and add-on family. She loved gardening, being outside in any season, and spending time at the family cabin. She was quick to laugh and always willing to help. Sandy was a great patriot, feisty to the very end, and she will be greatly missed.
A funeral service will be held at Dignity Memorial, Crouse-Kauber-Fraley Funeral Home in Johnstown, Ohio on January 10, 2026 at 11:00am.
