I don't even know what to say. Andy was my best friend throughout middle school, high school and college. We did everything together. My deepest condolences go out to the Zeitler family...such an immense loss. 

Andy always had a knack of being in the middle of it all.  Thanks for the great times and fast times!  You will be missed by many.  My deepest sympathies to all those who mourn the passing of Andy.  He had a large impact on those whom were bless to have know and loved him.  May you rest in peace and God bless your soul.
Jeff and Mia Banks 

Knew Andy from the time he was a newborn. What a happy kid ! Always pretty well behaved and he loved fun. I still cannot believe he has been taken so senselessly. Such a good young man. Cannot even imagine how his family is coping. God bless them all.

So sorry to hear of your son's passing. As hard as this time is, hopefully there are many great memories to remember Andy by. My prayers and thoughts go out to you and your entire family.


Carol and Dick - Words will never replace the loss of your incredible son - That being said - my heart bleeds for you and the family - when you get to Buffalo I would love to share time with you - I will never forget times spent together at the Windsor
With sympathy and much love Jean Covelli🙏🏼❤️


Very sorry to hear Andy has passed.  To never again see his smile and feel his energy is a real blow.  
Many of us who knew Andy years ago know that he spent a LOT of time in the pool.  He was a great swimmer and I was lucky to be his teammate in middle school and high school.  He knew he was faster than most - and getting ready on the blocks before the race he often let his competitors know it as well!
Andy and I were also soccer teammates a lot over the years - including into adulthood on co-ed teams.  
He was as tough an athlete as they come.  I was always happy to have him on my team - he wasn’t fun to play against!  
I’ll be missing you a lot buddy!

Worked with Andy in buffalo for many years.   I'm gonna miss you dude. Thanks for the smiles, help and memories.  I will never forget you. 

Scott Onanian


 Worked with Andy out of Marco great guy loved working with him. Lunches in key west. You will be missed my friend.


I worked with Andy on the Key West Express out of Marco Island and Fort Myers. We quickly became good friends. He was always smiling at work and a happy guy. I’ll never forget the time Andy, Tim, and myself went out for drinks on fort Myers beach after a maintenance day. We all got in my row boat and rowed across the bay to nervous nellies, then Liki Tiki then met up with Ernie and his family. It was a great time. Andy loved the beach. I miss you Andy. Love you bro.

We rode out the hurricane together in Key West with the Big Cat Express. Dinner and a beer there nightly until we caravanned home with water and groceries for coworkers hit by the storm. 
Andy was a good dude and a good crewman, and liked by everyone. He wanted to learn and advance within the crew and was well on his way. 
He'll certainly be missed.
Rest easy, brother.


I only got 10 months with him.  But it was truly a joy everyday I worked with him and when we out after work I never laughed and enjoyed myself with him like anyone else.  Lunch in Key West will never be the same. Sorry for your loss, Tim. 

Dear Carole, Dick & family.  There are no words to say that express this loss.  You are in our hearts, thoughts and prayers.   Love John & Sandy

Still can't believe you're gone. We miss you Andy so much!! 

This is a huge loss. Andy was a huge part of the Newton household. He was always over hanging out, not  only with Courtney but the whole family. He loved our dog and often made fun of my crazy hair in the morning. His laugh and smile were contagious. Thanks for the laughs and memories Andy. You will be missed and certainly remembered. 💙💙💙 


Dear Zeitler family, 
There are no words to express how very sorry I am for your loss. May God bring some comfort to your grief and some peace to your spirits. Please know I am keeping you all in my heart 💜 

Lynda DeLuca

The Zeitler boys. 
Andy will never be forgotten. Forever in our hearts. 
All our love to the family. 

Zeitler family 
Rest In Peace dear Andy , you are loved and will be missed 🙏🏻❤️🙏🏻

OBITUARY

Andy Zeitler

February 17, 1980 – October 8, 2022

Dengler, Roberts, Perna Funeral Home

Show your support

Add a Memory

Share Obituary

Get Reminders

Services