Should friends desire to send flowers for the service, please send directly to The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints 30522 Vía Con Dios, Rancho Santa Margarita, CA 92688. Flower delivery sho...

Carey Leon Penrod

October 24, 1963April 6, 2021

Dr. Carey L. Penrod, D.D.S. 10/24/1963 - 04/06/2021

On Tuesday, April 6, 2021, Dr. Carey Leon Penrod, loving husband, father, and grandfather, beloved son, brother, uncle, cousin, and friend, passed away after a two year battle with Severe Aplastic Anemia.

Carey was born to Annette and Leon Penrod on October 24, 1963 in Fullerton, California. He had a wonderful childhood, and especially loved all things outdoors. During his teenage years he spent his summers in Arizona visiting his grandparents and fishing with marshmallows, cheese, and worms on a string in the pond across the street! He also spent a few weeks for three summers with his Aunt Carol and Uncle Bob working on their farm in Idaho. Idaho held a special place in his heart. Even in his last days he was dreaming about buying property in Idaho for the ranch he’d hoped to run one day.

Carey met his wife Fawn while attending Seminary (an early morning church class) his Freshman year in high school. Over the next four years they became good friends and he helped her get a job at The Fullerton Daily News Tribune where he was working during his Senior year. They sat across from each other while handling the newspaper subscriptions and were able to talk and get to know each other well. They didn’t start dating until the day they graduated from high school and became inseparable for the two weeks before he left for BYU.

After graduating from Troy High School in 1981, Carey spent two years attending Brigham Young University before being called to serve an 18-month mission for the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in Santiago, Chile. He loved the people of Chile and enjoyed working in the mission office as the financial secretary. Two weeks after returning home from his mission, Carey proposed to his high school sweetheart, Fawn Henderson, and they were married in the Los Angeles Temple in 1984.

Carey always knew he wanted to be a dentist--he even wrote an essay in third grade about it! He earned his Bachelor of Science degree in Zoology from BYU in 1985, and his DDS from UCLA in 1989. He graduated cum laude and was inducted into the Omicron Kappa Upsilon National Dental Honor Society. After living for a short time in Crescent City, CA, Fawn and Carey settled in Oakdale, CA where he practiced dentistry for 10 years. Carey was very active in the local dental societies and study clubs, and was proud to be part of the “Cosmetic Revolution” in dentistry. In 2000, the Penrods moved to Orange County and Carey opened his own practice--Penrod Dental Care--in Rancho Santa Margarita. He and his team built a thriving practice founded on the principle Carey firmly believed in—“If you treat people right the rest will follow.” He loved dentistry, practicing for 30 years before retiring in 2019 after his diagnosis.

Carey was an active member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints his whole life. He served in many church positions including Elder’s Quorum President three times, teaching early-morning Seminary for four years, serving as a counselor in two Bishoprics, and as the Young Men’s President twice. He most enjoyed serving in the Scouting programs, especially as Scoutmaster. Carey earned his Eagle Scout award at age thirteen--one of the first to do this in Orange County! His love of Scouting never wavered. He shared his love of the mountains and rivers with many troops over the years, and while he might have struggled with remembering names, he could tell you the name of every stream of water he ever fished and would tell anyone willing to listen! Carey loved mentoring the young men, and was able to help many achieve the rank of Eagle Scout. For 12 years he served as the Saddleback District Eagle Project Advisor. On any given day you could find a young Scout at his dental office waiting for a last-minute signature on their project. Carey was awarded the District Award of Merit from the BSA in 2011.

In addition to his love of Scouting and his passion for dentistry, Carey’s weekends and holidays were filled with quality time with his kids and grandkids. Nearly every family reunion included helping his young grandkids press the button to launch model rockets into the sky and running to catch them before they were lost in the fields. He also enjoyed building and flying radio control gliders, using his ham radio, and working on his cabin in Holy Jim canyon. Carey loved to take his kids skiing and camping, as long as there was a river or stream nearby to indulge his favorite pastime, fishing--particularly fly fishing. Anyone who knew Carey knows he never felt more alive then when he had just hooked a good fish and fought it to the net. He made sure his kids would continue the tradition by teaching them young how to tie their own knots, hook and unhook their own fish, and he even taught his young daughters how to gut and clean their fish on their own!

More than anything--even fishing--Carey loved his wife, Fawn, fiercely. He always felt she was out of his league and never quite understood how he got so lucky to be her husband. He said it was the pleasure of his life being with her and raising their family together. In reflecting these past two years on his favorite memories together, he highlighted the time they spent in Yosemite, Hawaii, Yellowstone, and their favorite place on Earth--Island Park, ID. Beyond the beautiful scenery, though, Carey and Fawn most treasured the time they got to spend with their kids and grandkids. While he knew his life was being cut short, Carey reiterated multiple times how grateful he was that they had made the time and effort to be with each of their kids so often over the years.

After Carey’s diagnosis in March of 2019 and his bone marrow transplant 5 months later, he fought long and hard for two years spending time with family and friends, mentoring colleagues in the dental field, and reaching out to those he loved. While we feel our Dad and Grandpa left this world too soon and we miss him terribly, we know we will see him again and can’t wait for that happy reunion.

Carey leaves behind Fawn, his wife of 36 years; his six children: Christi (Jim Higham), Jeremy (Sierra Robinson), Annie (Russ Walker), Erin (Dave Rackham), Emma (Nick Bradford), Corinne (David Sexton); 11 grandchildren; his parents Annette and Leon Penrod; his siblings Teri (Scott Crawford), Steve, Brent (Julie Briegel); and numerous cousins, nieces, nephews.

A Celebration of Life will be held on April 17, 2021 at 10:00 a.m. at The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints located at 30522 Vía Con Dios, Rancho Santa Margarita, CA 92688. If you cannot attend but would like to watch, it will be broadcast through Zoom.

Pallbearers: Brent Penrod, Steve Penrod, Jeremy Penrod, James Higham, Russ Walker, Dave Rackham, Nick Bradford, David Sexton

Honorary Pallbearer: Leon Penrod, Scott Crawford, Cameron Crawford, Josh Miller, Derrick Crawford, Corbin Crawford, Michael Pickard, Tanner Pickard, Hunter Pickard, Brayden Pickard, Rylan Pickard, Todd Christensen



  • Celebration of Life

    Saturday, April 17, 2021

  • Celebration of Life Livestream

    Saturday, April 17, 2021



  • Private Graveside Service


Carey Leon Penrod

have a memory or condolence to add?

Ashlee Cato

April 17, 2021

When I think of Mr. Penrod, I think of two very distinct feelings I felt in his presence. He was the best dentist I ever had. I only ever felt comfort and kindness being his patient - I actually began to enjoy going to the dentist through finding him! But more importantly, I remember being in his home as a kid, spending time with his daughters and one of my best friends, Emma. And I distinctly remember how much I loved his love he had for his children and his wife. While it may seem silly, I have thought back to those everyday moments frequently from their home, and the admiration I felt for what he created with his family. He loved his family, and anyone in his home, there was no doubt - and as a child, is was so easily felt.

David Moss

April 17, 2021

I have always looked up to my cousin Carey. Sarah and I have been to Carey and Fawns house a few times and he has helped me know how to run a dental practice. Each time I followed his advice my dental office improved. Carey and Fawn let us stay at their house in 2017 for spring break when we went to Disneyland. They are very generous and kind. I talked to Carey on the phone a few days before he passed away. We talked about dentistry and family. I was impressed at how positive and caring he was even in his final days. I have five daughters so Carey was able to give me great advice from his experiences.

Maria Schmitt

April 14, 2021

Thank you Dr. Penrod for always being so kind and honest and always making me feel like no matter what , I was going to be taken care of ! Your generous heart and compassionate ways has changed the way I felt about dentistry.
Genuine Dentists are far and few and you dear Sir, has changed that for me! That is why I have been your patient for over 10 years
Thank you for taking care of me always!
God-bless you,
Maria Schmitt and family

Rick McClure

April 14, 2021

The McClure family loves the Penrods and will miss Carey dearly. Rick who will always cherish Carey as a friend, a mentor who helped fellowship him as a new convert to the Church, and the best college roommate a guy could ask for. Lezlie who loved Carey’s wit and his tolerance for Rick while navigating freshman year at BYU and lastly David, who appreciated the love and opportunity to meet and get to know Carey and Fawn who he grew up hearing so much about from his dads high school and college stories. Although our paths didn’t cross very often as time passed, Carey will always be an honored and cherished friend. Friendship is eternal. Until we meet again brother. With much love and sympathy.

The McClure family

Cheryl Espinoza

April 12, 2021

My condolences to the family. Dr. Penrod was so sweet kind and patient. I have anxieties and whenever I needed a root canal he was always so sweet and patient and made everything perfect. He will truly be missed .

Kimberly Baker

April 12, 2021

My sincerest condolences to the family. I do not believe i ever got Him as a dentist at the practice, But i know the practice he created is the best I have ever been to. Kind, compassionate, willing to go the extra mile, to be the angels they are, when your in pain. I am sure he was the reason behind that. I truly hope his legacy continues. I hope the family takes solace in the fact he is still helping people every day.

Sabra Marshall

April 12, 2021

Dr. Penrod was so sweet! I called the dental office when my son knocked out a front tooth because I didn't know who else to call.. Dr. Penrod was already out of the office because he was sick but he called me back late at night and helped me so much. My sincerest condolences to his family.

Arlys Oesterling

April 12, 2021

My husband, Robert Olson, and I were so saddened to get the news. We were impressed with the business he built and the care we received there. Since Robert is a retired internist, his praise of the medical care received by Penrod carries merit.

Our condolences to the family and we trust the business will continue in his honor.

Owen Harris

April 11, 2021

Many fond memories of Carey! I remember a scouting outing in the High Sierras. It was special to be with as he fished. He loved scouting and he was a great example to everyone. He had a very tender heart and was a friend to everyone.
Another very special experience was to be with the family in the San Diego Temple where I had the privilege to perform the marriage of Christi and Jim.
One of his best decisions was to marry Fawn.
Carey will truly be missed. May Gods choicest blessings be with all of his family at this time and until they joyfully meet again.
Owen Harris

Erika Hanson

April 10, 2021

My favorite memory was when Brother Penrod drove a large car full of beehives to girls camp., it was a very loud car ride for him:) While we were at camp, we kept our shoes outside of our tent and one morning I got up and put my foot into my shoe and there was a snake in it! Brother Penrod saved the day and came and took care of the snake and educated us on the type of snake it was and turned a scary situation for us girls into a learning experience.
Dr Penrod was always so friendly and kind and he will be so missed by so many. Prayers and comfort to his beautiful family