Mary Houston Hainkel Plummer passed away on November 14, 2026, at the age of 76. She was born in New Orleans on July 8, 1950. After graduating from the Academy of the Sacred Heart, she earned a bachelor’s degree in history from LSU, where she was an active member of Pi Beta Phi. She was a member of The Orleans Club and a former Queen of the Caliphs of Cairo. Her faith was very important to her, and she was a longtime parishioner of Holy Name of Jesus Catholic Church.
A true New Orleanian at heart, Mary walked the parade routes every Mardi Gras, celebrated many Mother’s Days with Irma Thomas at the Zoo, and attended Jazz Fests any chance she could, especially when her beloved Jimmy Buffett was performing. She could be found at Ricobono’s every Friday morning with her regular breakfast group of friends dating back decades or catching up with other loved ones over coffee across the city.
Mary never met a stranger, and she was a passionate defender of her family. She was devoted to her friends and above all to her four children and four grandchildren, who knew her affectionately as MiMi or GrandMiMi. She treasured time with her loved ones, especially during the holidays. She stood beside her people through illness, bereavement, and divorce, and she fiercely defended them - or let them know precisely where they went wrong - when she felt it was needed. You always knew exactly where you stood with Mary. Her Sacred Heart, LSU, Pi Beta Phi, and Holy Name communities brought her tremendous comfort, meaning, and joy through the good times and the bad. Her love and loyalty were returned in full.
She was preceded in death by her parents, John Jay Hainkel and Alida Bonnette Hainkel; her sister and best friend, Jane Hainkel Drennan; and her brother, John Jay Hainkel, Jr.
Mary is survived by her husband of 51 years, James Cordill Plummer; sons, James Plummer, Jr., Patrick Ryan Plummer, and Matthew Houston Plummer (Joanna); daughter, Molly Plummer Duncan (Richard); grandchildren, Mary Jane “MJ” Duncan, Elizabeth Ann “Lizzie” Duncan, Katherine Leigh “Kate” Duncan, and Lukas Marius Plummer; nephews, John J. Hainkel, III, David Torrey Drennan, and George Cameron Drennan; nieces, Juliet Hainkel, Alida Hainkel, and Holly Drennan Harrington; and great- and great-great-nieces and nephews, Andrew Harrington, Harris Drennan, Alex Hainkel, Olivia Hainkel, Roth Hainkel (Lacie), Amelia Hainkel, Scarlett Holton, Desiree Holton, and Mignon Holton.
Her family extends their sincere gratitude to the Academy of the Sacred Heart and Pi Beta Phi communities and to the lifelong friendships that came from both.
Relatives and friends are invited to attend the funeral services, officiated by Fr. Patrick Carr, at Lake Lawn Metairie Funeral Home, 5100 Pontchartrain Blvd., New Orleans, on Friday, November 20, 2026. Visitation will begin at 10 a.m., followed by a Funeral Mass at 12 p.m. Mary will be laid to rest at Metairie Cemetery immediately after the chapel service. A celebration of life will follow the burial at Southern Yacht Club beginning at 3 p.m.
In lieu of flowers, the family kindly asks that memorial donations be made to the Lewy Body Dementia Resource Center, 28 Highwood Drive, Northport, NY 11768, or online at lewybodyresourcecenter.org/donate.